I use to use Milani's Color Brilliance Eye Pencil but heard that the Liquif'eye line was better with not smudging. Peep it...
Product Name: Milani Liquif Eye Metallic Eye Liner Pencil
Price: Approx. $5 USD
Packaging: Normal pencil form.
Texture: Very soft; I have to sharpen it at least once a week. Great for topping off with black eye shadow.
Staying Power: Great for top lining; I've always had a problem with smudging on my waterline but noticed that this has better staying power than the Color Brilliance. 9/10 overall in my opinion.
I also have 3 other colors that the homegirl was kind enough to send me but haven't had the chance to use yet. I'll swatch those shortly to show you all. I will also do a side by side comparison with the Color Brilliance pencils. (^___^)
Be easy everyone! XOXO, ~L